Friday, December 14, 2012

County explores new means to prepare budgets


The county's code enforcement office wasn't doing very well. It had lost both of its officers, and the county was under pressure to enforce a variety of rules.

But one of the rules it wasn't under any pressure to enforce was the home occupation permit. The cost of the permits wasn't covering the cost of the program. There wasn't any controversy dealing with home businesses in the county.

So, according to County Manager Steve Mokrohisky, Community Development Director Mimi Moss and her staff decided to ask commissioners to delete the requirement, allowing the code enforcement officer to pursue a far more profitable task.

“That's something they did on their own,” he said.

But it also serves as an example of how priority based budgeting works.

Priority based budgeting doesn't necessarily pit emergency services against the library. It drills down to actual programs offered by the county, 702 to be exact, ranks them based on scores, and allows commissioners to determine their relative merit.

Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Participatory Budgeting Meets Priority Based Budgeting in Douglas County


Citizen engagement in the budget process has been increasingly of interest in our work at the Center for Priority Based Budgeting over the last few years. The logic follows that the more citizens can authentically contribute and influence the decisions being made by their government, the more ownership they might take in their community. Trust increases with transparency. Compassion comes with trust. The benefits are undeniable.

Still, organizations ask us, "but what about the risks inherent in citizen engagement? What is the right role for citizens?" We're asked, "to what degree is it appropriate, safe, meaningful, realistic and effective to have citizens participate in decision making?" Pete Peterson, one of the nation's leading experts in the field and Executive Director of Pepperdine University's Davenport Institute of Public Policy pushed us to recognize the difference between citizen engagment as a means to an end, or an end in of itself.

In our work, we continue to strive for answers to these questions - they are the right questions. With the potential for such great outcomes, if we can answer them correctly and involve citizens in more meanigful and influential ways, we are moved to try and answer the questions.

For at least a glimpse at what is possible, and an inspirational glimpse at that, we are pleased to share with you Douglas County, Nevada's experience in putting citizens in the driver's seat of their Priority Based Budgeting process. Special thanks to Peak Democracy - our partners in the development of the County Budget Challenge.

Click Here for the Article Just Published in the Carson Valley's Record Courier
NOVEMBER, 30 2012
BY SHEILA GARDNER - SGARDNER@RECORDCOURIER.COM

Mandee Guariglia has lived in Carson Valley for 14 years. She and her husband have two boys, and she works part-time. Despite her busy schedule, Guariglia took time out Thursday to participate in the Douglas County budget challenge at the Minden library branch.

“It sounded like a good idea, to put your voice where you want taxpayers money to go,” she said.

Tuesday, November 27, 2012

City of Cincinnati Releases Most Comprehensive and Transparent Documentation of Priority Based Budgeting's Impact on City Programs


The City of Cincinnati, Ohio has released their 2013 Recommended Budget, addressing a $34 million deficit through cuts and cost shifting, savings, new revenues, embedded growth, and one-time sources.

The City’s use of Priority Based Budgeting (through their Priority Driven Budgeting initiative) establishes one of the greatest advancements in the use of the process to guide policy direction. The City’s response to Council’s policy direction provides one of the most comprehensive evaluations of city services across the entire organization.

Many organizations have approached us with a strong desire to bring their elected officials into a constructive and transparent discussion about the budget – Cincinnati has set the bar high in this respect. In the most direct way possible, the City used Priority Based Budgeting to guide policy-oriented discussions.  One of the benefits of the process is that it creates specific roles for elected officials to participate and succeed. When elected officials can focus on key policy questions that impact resource allocation, when they’re provided input and transparency in the way their policy questions are answered, and when they can make decisions based on policy impacts, then they’ve played a successful role in budgeting.

The following comes from the City’s 2013 Recommended Budget:

Council Policy Direction 
(Click here to see the detailed policy direction from City Council, as well as staff’s response, using Priority Driven Budgeting)

In June, the City Council received the results of the Priority-Driven Budgeting initiative and provided this budget policy motion with direction for formulating the 2013/2014 Operating Budget: “That the Administration construct a budget based on the following factors:

Use the information from the Priority-Driven Budget process to:
  • Recommend elimination or reduction of functions based upon whether other organizations or entities are serving the same populations or providing the same function. If this is the case, the administration should outline a method of transitioning individuals to the other services or programs.
  • Recommend changes to mandated programs that exceed the minimum requirements of the mandate.
  • Identify functions that can be shared with other political jurisdictions.
  • Identify functions that, rather than eliminate them, can be made self sufficient through the establishment of a fee structure.”


The Diagnostic Tool provided data to start discussions about the programs and services we provide to help the City analyze programs and services for cost savings, revenue enhancements and budget reductions. All of the analysis conducted allowed the City to more strategically allocate resources, and provide citizens more transparency, as well as a clearer understanding of the budget decision as we move forward.

While it is the first year Cincinnati has engaged in priority-driven budgeting to this extent, it provides a foundation for examining the services and programs the City provides that are important to the people the City serves.

Click here to see a detailed program listing – the budget status of every City Program in PBB terms: the status of each program in terms of which are increased, decreased, receive no funding change, become reorganized, or are under review.

Wednesday, November 21, 2012

Relevance First - Wisdom from the Results Based Budgeting Act of Alberta, Canada

http://icma.org/en/icma/knowledge_network/blogs/blogpost/925/Relevance_First__Wisdom_in_the_Results_Based_Budgeting_Act_of_Alberta_Canada


The Center for Priority Based Budgeting is honored to contract with the Province of Alberta, to help implement Results Based Budgeting as the process has been initiated across the entire Provincial Government. It is the largest initiative CPBB has ever been involved with, and we’ll be anxious to share the stories and lessons we learn along the way.
“Result-based budgeting is about outcomes. The process is a comprehensive three year review that will look at all government programs and services, ensuring each one aligns with the outcomes that Albertans have identified as priorities. This review will ensure that government programs and services are meeting their intended goals and are being delivered in the most efficient and effective way possible. 
Results-based budgeting is not about reducing budgets to meet an arbitrary spending reduction target, although savings are expected. It’s about budgeting to achieve results, rather than adding incrementally to the prior year’s budget. The focus is as much about effectiveness as it is about efficiency. Significant value will not come from simply making an ineffective program run efficiently.”

Friday, November 16, 2012

Center for Priority Based Budgeting Unveils the Breakthrough Approach Equipping Communities to Survive in Tumultuous Fiscal Environment


The National League of Cities letter urging Congressional Leaders to responsibly address issues related to the "fiscal cliff," brings into focus the consequences of "indiscriminate cuts" and points out the "devastating impact" on local governments.

The Center for Priority Based Budgeting is honored to present at this year's NLC conference in Boston, as part of the Leadership Training sessions on Thursday, November 29th. During this session, we will be sharing the tools and techniques of Priority Based Budgeting through Fiscal Health & Wellness that have equipped communities with an entirely new way of ensuring scarce resources are allocated to the most relevant and effective programs they offer.

Monday, November 12, 2012

Douglas County, Nevada Launches Participatory Budgeting - Citizens Influence County's Entire Budget Process


Douglas County, Nevada launches participatory budgeting with residents - advancing their implementation of Priority Based Budgeting with CPBB's and Peak Democracy's "$500 Exercise."

Residents can try their hand at county budgeting

For years, pundits and politicians have argued that government should be run like a business, tossing about terms like “zero-based and priority-based budgeting, and across-the-board cuts.”

What about bringing the process down a notch, and running it like a household budget: Setting aside a certain amount for expenses which must be covered, and cutting the luxuries in lean times?

Douglas County officials are inviting the public to participate in the “budget challenge,” an online program on the county's website that allows participants to try their hand at dispersing $500 among county services.

Thursday, October 11, 2012

Priority Based Budgeting - Local Government's version of BIG DATA?

We're just back from a week of life-changing, wildly beyond-belief events that were collectively referred to as the ICMA Conference. Gratitude doesn't begin to encompass what we're feeling.

At the closing of his key-note address, Jim Collins urged us all to "be useful." To be part of the launch of ICMA's Center for Management Strategies, to see Priority Based Budgeting declared a Leading Practice, to see our own community's practitioners (from Fort Collins, Wheat Ridge, Walnut Creek, Cincinnati, Blue Ash, Post Falls, Boulder, Chandler and others) being recognized for their achievements and what they've been able to do with PBB to make significant and lasting cultural changes in their communities...well, what we're feeling is that we're part of something bigger than ourselves - we're partners in something truly "useful!" Wow...

Among the many reflections, however, one of the most unusual and yet eye-opening was a comment that what is making this work so "useful," is the possibility that Priority Based Budgeting might be local government's version of BIG DATA.

New to the term, we looked it up: BIG DATA - a collection of data sets so large and complex that it becomes difficult to process using on-hand database management tools. The challenges include capture, curation, storage,[4] search, sharing, analysis,[5] and visualization. The trend to larger data sets is due to the additional information derivable from analysis of a single large set of related data, as compared to separate smaller sets with the same total amount of data, allowing correlations to be found to "spot business trends, determine quality of research, prevent diseases, link legal citations, combat crime, and determine real-time roadway traffic conditions."

(And for further interest, here's a podcast from the Harvard Business Review: http://blogs.hbr.org/ideacast/2012/10/big-data-solves-big-problems.html)

What a possibility!

PBB as BIG DATA

In our work, our communities are showing us how the PBB model is unlocking previously undiscovered answers to questions they've been asking for a long-time:

•        What is the local government uniquely qualified to provide, for the maximum benefit to citizens for the tax dollars they pay?
•        What is the community truly mandated to provide? What does it cost to fulfill those mandates?
•        What are the appropriate programs to consider establishing or increasing user-fees?
•        What are the appropriate programs to consider partnerships with other community service providers?
•        What services might the local government reach consensus about “getting out of the business” of providing?
•        Where are there apparent overlaps and redundancies in a community where several entities are providing similar services?
•        Where is the local government potentially competing against businesses in its own community?

We chose "a Unique Lens" as the tagline for our non-profit for exactly this reason - our communities are seeing things we haven't seen before, as if they had a new tool with which to see their world. Our entire September 2012 PM Magazine article struck the same note: "Challenges facing local governments today literally requires a new way to see. It’s as if our vision has been blurred by the extraordinary stress of managing in this complex economic environment. Whether attempting to rebuild in a post-recession climate, or persevering through another year of stagnating or declining revenues, the challenge remains: how to allocate scarce resources to achieve our community’s highest priorities. Through the new lens of Fiscal Health and Wellness through Priority Based Budgeting, which provides powerful insights, local governments are making significant breakthroughs.”

Is this BIG DATA in play?

We don't know, but we're excited. Thanks to Walnut Creek's Lorie Tinfow for your never-ending insights into what you're seeing form our work together. Leave it to the Stanford grad to bring BIG DATA into the conversation - as it's been from the first day we met you, you have changed us forever, again!

The new lens of priority-based budgeting makes it possible for elected officials, citizens, decision-makers and staff to agree and:
•        To see how to align scarce resources with the highest priorities of our communities.
•        To see the most appropriate service provider for the programs we offer.
•        To see what services residents are willing to pay for.
•        To see public and private-sector partnerships ripe for leveraging.                                                                    
•        To ultimately see a new way of determining which  services our local government is best suited to provide—services that have the greatest impact for the resources within the community’s means.

Tuesday, October 2, 2012

Tonight in Cincinnati! Citizens Invited To Continue the Conversation On Priority-Driven Budgeting Initiative


http://cincinnati-oh.gov/cityofcincinnati/city-events/budget-conversation-continues/

The City's Office of Budget & Evaluation is using data gathered from the Priority-Driven Budgeting initiative to analyze programs and services for cost savings, revenue enhancements and budget reductions.

Departments are identifying programs and services which can be divested, provided with other departments or outside partners, provided at lower levels of service and cost, and/or be provided with increased revenues or fees.

City Manager Milton Dohoney, Jr. will use these data and analysis in conjunction with policy direction from City Council to form his recommended budget, which he will submit to the Mayor and City Council in mid-November.

Additionally, citizens may comment on the City Manager's Recommended Budget during the Budget & Finance Committee's public meetings later this year.

Thursday, September 27, 2012

Douglas County Readies for Year 2 in PBB; Welcomes Citizen Engagement




Douglas County, Nevada - PBB Update:

PBB Is:
 A new and long-term organizational change in the budgeting process to assist in understanding, and evaluating County programs and services
 A tool to find opportunities to discuss shifting resources based on priorities
 A tool to identify programs with additional cost recovery opportunities
 A tool to identify programs with possible alternative service providers/regional collaboration
 A tool to assist the Board in appropriating available resources in the Budget


PBB Is Not:
 A recipe for budget cuts
 A tool to tell elected officials how to allocate their funding amongst the programs and services they provide


Priority Based Budgeting
 A new “lens” that provides communities, elected officials, and departments with powerful insights into their programs
 Programs are prioritized based on their relevance to achieving the community’s desired results
 Program costs are calculated including all resources utilized across the organization




http://www.douglascountynv.gov/Files/AgendaCenter/Agendas/80/October%201,%202012%20Priority%20Based%20Budgeting%20Workshop%20Supporting%20Materials.pdf

Tuesday, September 25, 2012

City of Cincinnati Takes Priority Based Budgeting Conversation Back to Citizens

The City's Office of Budget & Evaluation is using data gathered from the Priority-Driven Budgeting initiative to analyze programs and services for cost savings, revenue enhancements and budget reductions.

Departments are identifying programs and services which can be divested, provided with other departments or outside partners, provided at lower levels of service and cost, and/or be provided with increased revenues or fees.

http://www.cincinnati-oh.gov/cityofcincinnati/city-events/budget-conversation-continues/

Thursday, September 13, 2012

City of Boulder's PBB Breakthroughs - a Multi-Year Perspective

The City of Boulder continues it's ideal application of Priority Based Budgeting, evolving the process into their third year.

What Boulder has done is remarkable in many way, but we wanted to highlight two significant outcomes:
1.) Applying PBB to "new programs" - Boulder was the first to apply PBB to the consideration of programs that didn't exist before; running them through the PBB model to see what Quartile they might be in, if they were initiated. It's a tremendous application. And as demonstrated in this year's budget, new investment, new resources are allocated to high priority programs planning the City's "energy future." Where did they get the money to start these new programs - "nearly 10% reductions were applied to low-quartile, low-relevance investment areas. "http://extras.mnginteractive.com/live/media/site21/2012/0830/20120830_041603_boulderbudget2013.pdf
2.) The long-term view of PBB - Boulder has also compiled a multi-year perspective on their application of PBB, to demonstrate how they've reduced and divested themselves of lower priority programs over the years, and reinvested in new or expanded higher priority programs - it's outstanding!

Thursday, September 6, 2012

PBB Breakthrough: Telling Your Story – How Walnut Creek Communicates to Citizens, Transforming their Budget to a Narrative

http://issuu.com/walnutcreekarcs/docs/wcbudget?mode=window&viewMode=doublePage


The City of Walnut Creek, California is among the earliest-adopters of Priority Based Budgeting, having first implemented the process in 2009. As Priority Based Budgeting Week continues, we wanted to share with you one of the most significant breakthroughs to date in the work – highlighting what the City has done on their own to transform the way they communicate about the budget with their citizens.

So many of us are working so hard to make headway in “authentic citizen engagement.” It’s not easy! One of our fundamental objectives in creating the “unique lens” of Priority Based Budgeting was and continues to be offering a way to “see” the budget in a way that is so easy, so clear, any citizen, any elected official, any staff member, anybody could understand immediately how decisions are made. Not only that, but we want to make it so clear what decisions and what options are open to us; to provide clarity where it’s sometimes uncertain – that was much of the focus of this September’s PM Magazine article.

This advancement from Walnut Creek offers such hope and excitement about what’s possible. The City is pioneering in so many ways, not just Priority Based Budgeting, and we encourage you to reach out to them (contact Assistant City Manager / Administrative Services Director, Lorie Tinfow at tinfow@walnut-creek.org).

With the “2012-2014 Budget Story,” we are so pleased to introduce you yet another innovation from Walnut Creek!

“A Community Connected: The 2012-14 Budget Story,” seeks to share our budget information in a new way. It identifies what we plan to do over the next two years with the resources placed under our stewardship. It explains the processes we’ve put in place with the community to set the goals that guided our budget decisions. And it tells our story in a way that we hope will be more engaging and easy to follow, using graphics, photos and short stories.”
 - City Manager, Ken Nordhoff, from Page 1: The 2012-2014 Budget Story


After "Internal" Implementation of PBB, Billings Opens Process to Citizen Influence



The Billings City Council really wants to know what its constituents think.

Next week, the council and city staff members will hold three public meetings around town to discuss the Citizen Survey results and to get feedback on two major issues: the city budget and public safety.

The city is planning to implement a process called “priority-based budgeting.” City Administrator Tina Volek will be at the Community Conversations to explain how this process is supposed to work. The city needs to rethink its budget because costs have been growing faster than revenues even as the city has grown.


Tuesday, September 4, 2012

Center for Management Strategies: Priority Based Budgeting Library of Resources

As ICMA's Center for Management Strategies Director, Cheryl Hilvert, mentioned in her blog post last week, the "official launch" of the new Center is taking place at the conference in Phoenix. To help kick-off the "official launch," these next two weeks will feature a host of in-depth blog posts on the first two leading practices: Fiscal Health and Wellness through Priority Based Budgeting, and the High Performing Organization (HPO) model.

This week being Priority Based Budgeting week, we wanted to start it off by assembling the published works on Fiscal Health and Priority Based Budgeting, all in one place. Each published article and white paper is yours by clicking on the links below. Our objective is to add to this library, which we will do this week even, posting articles and stories from the front-lines of communities who have implemented this work (stay tuned this week for two posts about the incredible achievements in Walnut Creek, California and Boulder, Colorado).
We also wanted to devote Priority Based Budgeting week to generating the kinds of questions from you all that we would typically generate during our webinars or conference sessions, and dedicate time to answering you. Look for your opportunity to contribute to an ongoing Q&A session on Priority Based Budgeting this week, and take advantage of the chance to pose your questions. We're so much looking forward to hearing what you have to say!
CPBB Publications on Priority Based Budgeting
September 2012Seeing Things Differently: Through the Lens of Priority-Based Budgeting, Communities Gain Powerful Insights into Their Programs, authored by Jon Johnson and Chris Fabian, published by International City / County Manager's Association's (ICMA) professional journal, Public Management "PM" Magazine
Description: Priority Based Budgeting has been declared a Leading Practice for Government Management by ICMA. Three years after it's invention, the process has been implemented in over 30 communities across the Country, from cities as large as Sacramento CA, and Cincinnati OH to communities as politically complex and diverse as Boulder CO and Monterey CA, to organizations as small as Post Falls ID, Chrisitansburg VA and Blue Ash OH. The "unique lens" of Priority Based Budgeting is leading organizations to surprising breakthroughs and insights, focusing on questions such as: What is the local government uniquely qualified to provide, for the maximum benefit to citizens for the tax dollars they pay? What is the community truly mandated to provide? What does it cost to fulfill those mandates? What are the appropriate programs to consider establishing or increasing user-fees? What are the appropriate programs to consider partnerships with other community service providers? What services might the local government reach consensus about “getting out of the business” of providing? Where are there apparent overlaps and redundancies in a community where several entities are providing similar services? Where is the local government potentially competing against businesses in its own community?
March 2011White Paper: Anatomy of a Priority Driven Budget Process, authored by Chris Fabian, Jon Johnson and GFOA's Shayne Kavanagh, published by the Government Finance Officer's Association (GFOA) as a White Paper
Description: This White Paper, published by GFOA, is the first paper documenting some of the key ingredients of a Priority Based Budget initiative. While most governments today agree on the need to prioritize services and resource allocation, the key issue remains: how do you do that? This is a paper about the Center for Priority Based Budgeting's methodologies and process which are pioneering in the field of priority based budgeting, as well as some of CPBB's most successful stories from the work, namely: San Jose, Lakeland, Walnut Creek, Blue Ash, Grand Island, Chesapeake, Boulder and Fairfield. To quote Chesapeake's City manager in 2010, William Harrell: "It sounds intuitive but what we found was there was no real methodology to connect all of the things that government does" to what policymakers want to see for their cities. (Virginia Pilot, regional newspaper, Chesapeake, Virginia)
May 2010Anatomy of a Priority Based Budget, authored by Jon Johnson, Chris Fabian and GFOA's Shayne Kavanagh, published by the Government Finance Officer's Association's (GFOA) professional journal, Government Finance Review (GFR)
Description: Priority Driven Budgeting is about how a government should invest resources in order to meet its stated objectives. Prioritization helps us to better articulate why the programs we offer exist, what value they offer to citizens, how they benefit the community, what price we pay for them, and what objectives and citizen demands they are achieving. Priority Driven Budgeting is about directing resources to those programs that create the greatest value for the public." CPBB has contributed to GFOA's research since 2008 when Johnson and Fabian's Priority-based Budgeting session drew over 800 at GFOA's Annual Conference in Florida. On the front-lines of the "New Normal" throughout these last few years, CPBB's experiences formed the basis for GFOA's objective research about how local governments are not only surviving, but creating great transformations in their organizations and their communities. These are some of the stories and lessons learned from 2008-2010 - the success stories of Walnut Creek and San Jose, California, and the City of Lakeland, Florida.
June 2008Prioritization: The New Reality of Budgeting, authored by Chris Fabian, Scott Collins and Jon Johnson, published by International City / County Manager's Association's (ICMA) professional journal, Public Management "PM" Magazine
Description: Unveiling the invention of Priority Based Budgeting, the authors note: "the biggest challenge we face in government is not the ever-changing fiscal conditions. Instead, the issue most often is a crisis of strategy. Recognizing this, we believe that implementing prioritization is an effective way to combat crises. All organizations, especially those that are stewards of public resources, establish values and objectives to meet the expectations of those for whom they exist to serve. Resources contributed by the community or other constituencies are dedicated to achieve those established objectives, regardless of the current fiscal condition. As we evaluate the inventories of all programs and services offered, we would find it implausible to believe that each achieves those objectives to an equal extent. Prioritization offers an objective process that allows those responsible for resource allocation decisions to ensure that those programs of higher value to citizens, those programs that achieve the organization’s objectives most visibly and effectively, can be sustained through adequate funding levels regardless of the fiscal crisis du jour. Whether there are more resources to distribute or fewer to allocate, prioritization guides that allocation toward those programs most highly valued by the organization and, most important, by the citizens who depend on those programs for their well-being, their comfort, and their expected quality of life."
CPBB Publications on Fiscal Health
October 2009, It’s All in the Questions – The Manager's Role in Achieving Fiscal Health (Part 2), authored by Jon Johnson and Chris Fabian, published by International City / County Manager's Association's (ICMA) professional journal, Public Management "PM" Magazine
Description: When elected officials start asking if it's time to cut services, cut staff, or raise taxes, are you confident you have the facts and analyses to offer a thoughtful recommendation? Be prepared with an approach that uses a series of basic but critical diagnostic questions that center around five measures of fiscal health. In October 2009, PM Magazine published Part 2 in the "It's All in the Questions" series which highlighted the public manager's role in assessing the organization's Fiscal Health. With special emphasis on the effectiveness of Internal Service Funds and the success of scenario planning models such as the Fiscal Health Diagnostic Tool, this article helps put in place the final foundation of financial stability needed so that an organization can look to Priority Based Budgeting with a sound footing.
September 2009It’s All in the Questions – The Manager's Role in Achieving Fiscal Health (Part 1), authored by Jon Johnson and Chris Fabian, published by International City / County Manager's Association's (ICMA) professional journal, Public Management "PM" Magazine
Description: "It's All in the Questions - the Manager's Role in Achieving Fiscal Health" is the latest Cover Story for Pubic Management Magazine, and includes Part 1 of a 2 part series, with Part 1 focusing on the critical identification and differentiation between reliable, predicatable, ongoing revenues and those of a one-time nature; establishing and demonstrating reserves; and understanding and addressing variances.
For any further questions, interest or ideas on Priority Based Budgeting, contact Cheryl Hilvert at chilvert@icma.org 
http://icma.org/en/icma/knowledge_network/blogs/blogpost/794/Center_for_Management_Strategies_Brings_You_Priority_Based_Budgeting_Library_of_Resources